Sunday, March 2, 2008

What's my motivation?

I have thus far refrained from ranting about the destructive consequences of climate change - we get a lot of that from all directions... But I thought it would be interesting to try to articulate why I personally think this is such an important issue - not to convince others, but rather to understand it myself. So, here's the beginning of an attempt to articulate my motivation - a work in progress, perhaps:
  • The consequences of climate change will be devastating for all life. I won't go into much detail here - see "The Weather Makers" by Tim Flannery for more information. This, in itself, is a reason, but it also feeds into deeper motivations, both as an individual and as a part of a greater whole:
    • I want to protect myself and the things I love. I plan on having kids some day. I feel a responsibility to them to pass on this world as intact as possible, complete with biodiversity, clean drinking water, peace, and the opportunity to live a fulfilling life. It sounds trite, but this is a motivating factor. Sometimes I'm inclined to get cynical about the human race (both about civilization's future survival as well as whether we deserve to survive at all). But then I remember all the individuals in my life and how much I love them. Humans really are worth working for. So are all the places and species, the natural communities, the rocks, mountains, rivers and lakes that I experience and enjoy.
    • I'm part of a greater whole. That statement is true on a spiritual, scientific and philosophical level - the fate of the Earth and the community of life impacts me on a spiritual, physical and intellectual level. I'm not just worried that 3 out of every 5 species are expected to go extinct by the end of the century under a business as usual scenario (Flannery, 2005) because I think polar bears are cute (though I do). It upsets me because I am intrinsically connected; the devastating loss of life and diversity devastates me because I am a part of all this. Likewise, even if I'm not one of the 200 million people displaced by rising seas (Stern Review, 2007), I am part of a global community, the wellbeing of which affects me.
  • As a first world citizen from the world's greatest perpetrator - the US of A - I feel responsibility for the consequences of climate change. Likewise, I feel a responsibility to do what I can to stop it.
  • Sometimes I think climate change presents an opportunity (?): a chance to rethink and reconstruct not only our relationship to the Earth but also our relationship with each other; a chance to rekindle the dwindling community spirit, a chance to revise our systems and institutions to make them more equitable; a chance to disrupt the power structure from the local to the regional to the global level.
I get really cynical sometimes. For example, I recently found out that emissions in the last several years have surpassed the IPCC's worst-case scenario (Raupach et al, 2007). Surprisingly, I suppose, a sense of hopelessness and inevitability does not decrease my drive. This is a moral quest, not an intellectual one (yes, I'm taking the word "moral" back from the Right). The passion that I feel cannot be easily diminished by poor odds. Just as I would do all I could for a loved one who only had a 1% chance of survival, so will I continue to fight.

2 comments:

Mike said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mike said...

"In the past six weeks, the nation's gasoline consumption has fallen by an average 1.1% from year-earlier levels, according to weekly government data.

That's the most sustained drop in demand in at least 16 years, except for the declines that followed Hurricane Katrina in 2005, which temporarily knocked out a big chunk of the U.S. gasoline supply system."

^From WSJ